Hi,
this is normal because condition have 2 ways, so:
Condition 1
if equal to custom value 3 show Graduation Year, Jersey number, ... else hide Graduation Year, Jersey number,...
Condition 3
if equal to custom value 1 show Graduation Year else hide Graduation Year
Result
if I select value 3
Condition 1 - show Graduation Year
Condition 3 - hide Graduation Year

To solve this you need to make something like this:
options
0|Fan
4|Alumni
2|Parent
3|Active Player
1|Coach

Condition 1: if equal to custom value 3 show Jersey number, ... (remove graduation year from condition)
Condition 3: if great than custom value 2 show Graduation Year

Now Results
Condition 1: do nothing on graduation year
Condition 3: show Graduation Year